Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Homework Stinks


"Homework stinks."
 If you're a teacher, you've heard this before. If you're a parent, you've heard, or maybe have even said, this before. As a student, you've almost certainly uttered this phrase in response to the workload assigned  by your teacher/s. Why is the phrase so universal among students and the practice so despised? While my thinking on homework continues to evolve, the phrase is approaching a truism for me. Even though my philosophy and practices are still not aligned, I am getting closer to the coherency that I would like to achieve.

I had the opportunity to complete my Masters Degree this summer and aside from that achievement, I was able to devote a significant amount of my classwork towards the role of homework in our classroom. I've had a draft post on the topic for some time now, but the topic is so complex that I just never could seem to commit the time needed to address in a way that I felt it deserved. So I'm going to 'eat the elephant' one post at a time, four in total.

What the posts will try and accomplish or address:
  1. Start the conversation. I'll try to get people thinking about homework and provide some background on homework, its issuance, tradition, and new thinking on the topic.
  2. Tackle the homework issue from a student and home partner perspective. Its impact on learning, personal interests, relationships, and motivation.
  3. Look at homework from an Teacher's perspective. What are teachers, administrators roles in homework and how do their attitudes and practices (issuance/grading) impact student learning and motivation.
  4. My verdict on the issue for my students. What I will try and do and maintain for the benefit of student learning and motivation.
Even as I write the outline for these posts, the task seems too large, but here I go. I'm an elementary teacher so my perspective on the topic addresses homework solely from that perspective. Feel free to visit my Delicious bookmarks on the subject (tag: homework)

Homework and its issuance have been a part of classrooms school culture since the one room classroom of Laura Ingalls. The issuance of homework is entrenched in not only teaching theory, but in the daily practice of the modern classroom. Homework has been considered the "job of childhood" (Cornos/Xu 2004) and just an assumed part of school life and learning. Many teachers assign homework as a way of helping the school-home connection, build responsibility (self regulation), to develop self-directed behavior, and as repetitive practice of concepts learned in the classroom. Some research has found that homework can develop student self efficacy, enhance learning, and improve performance on standardized tests. (Cooper 2001; Hong 2011; Ramdass 2011;Trautwein 2004, 2006)

Some however, have called homework 'the most reliable extinguisher of the flame of curiosity" (Alfie Kohn.The Atlantic 2009) Many teachers are starting to understand that despite increasing pressure to cover multiple content standards, navigate sometimes competing direction from administrators, and loss of class time that homework is not an answer to student learning. There is a growing movement that seeks to either alter or eliminate the practice of homework issuance. Here is a prominent example http://www.endtherace.org/




"Break the legs of an old tradition" - Italian proverb

Some questions around homework.
  • Why do teachers assign homework?
  • What does homework contribute to student learning? Is it an effective practice and is it based in sound instructional theory?
  • What, if any, conditions need to be met for homework to be a productive practice?
  • Should homework be graded?
  • What is the social impact of homework?
  • Is the impact of homework the same for all students? Low income youth?
  • Can teachers claim or demand time outside of their classroom? And does homework take away from student creativity or the development of their personal interests?
  • Does homework facilitate deeper home partner relationships and involvement in student academics? Or does it add stress and frustration to students and their home partners?
  • Does homework improve the home-school connection?
  • What in terms of assessment or feedback does homework produce? Is the educational product valuable?
  • Is homework the result of poorly planned lessons or mismanaged class time?
Tell me what you think. I'd love to hear where your thinking is. Thanks for reading. The second post of this series is here. Homework Stinks #2 Students and Home Partners


  twitter-7a.png
Get Follow Me Buttons

9 comments:

  1. I 'killed off' homework last week with my 4th grade kids. We're halfway through the school year and after 11 years of teaching and wondering 'what's this all about?' I decided to do some proper reading on the subject. Thanks to many people in my twitter PLN, I decided to set up 'home learning' instead. Sounds like a trite language trick, but it is far more than that. Goodbye homework, hello choice, negotiation, self-control, autonomy, variety, enthusiasm, learning, diversity, differentiation - happy times.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I forgot to mention that your post here is the equal of any I've read on this matter. I'll be reading more. Thanks

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the kind words and the encouragement. I appreciate it.

      Delete
  3. Well said! I got to talk with middle school teachers in my district about homework last year and their thoughts echo many of yours. We all read "Rethinking Homework" (Vatterott) together and found many of the ideas in there helpful. The teachers all tried different techniques with varying levels of success. Bottom line: Teachers who didn't call it "homework" or "formative assessment" found that terminology change useful, and teachers who somehow communicated the PURPOSE of homework (and SHOWED the purpose rather than telling) were more successful.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks. I know at the very base of homework issuance is a desire by teachers to do what they feel is best for their students, but homework tasks affects a number of things for the student. You're point is well taken and that aligns with some research on grade 8 Swiss students, that found when motivation on the part of the students was high and the purpose of homework was understood to be beneficial by those students, the result was improved effort and completion.

      Delete
  4. We give very little homework in our grade level (2nd) besides free choice reading each night. We all have the same "homework" sets that go home each week but I started revamping my set about 4 years ago because so much of it was meaningless. I cut it to the minimum instead of removing it altogether because of the dreaded, "the third grade teachers will say I am not preparing them for their homework load." Last year at the end of school, I created a homework menu. They students could choose 5 out of the 10 menu items. Some of the items were: add a post on our kidblog, read and share an article from online or from a newspaper, choose a science experiment and share the results, write a story on storybird, play a math game, etc... The kids had a great time and they said they liked it so much better. I want to do more of this. :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. I certainly understand the 'not preparing them" argument, but I teach middle school content and students not high school (or higher grade) rigor. I love the choice menu! What a great idea. I also like the creative options that are part of your 'homework'. Gives me something to think about. Thanks for reading.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I've found a re-visit of student goals quite enlightening for this process too. Using these to agree upon a 'menu' is really powerful.

    ReplyDelete
  7. It's really good that you mention the alignment of student goals with the work they do at home. This combination has been found to have positive results in some of the studies I've read. I'm intrigued by the menu of options, but I need to think about what and how I would use the method for my kids.

    ReplyDelete